Democracy in decline
Today, the BJP, with its
Hindutva ideology, its allies, and others who have helped it attain absolute power through mass defections, has contributed
to what many see as a serious decline in our democracy. There is no
longer a level playing field, as the ruling party, led by the Prime Minister of India, appears to utilise every possible lever of power—ranging from the Election Commission, with minimal regard for Model Code of Conduct restrictions, to enforcement
agencies and the authority of the central government. This influence now extends across northern, eastern, and western states,
with significant inroads being
made in the south. Although elections continue to be held and there is widespread celebration among “we the people” regarding development and material progress, it is important to look beyond appearances and reflect on the broader state of the world today.
One observes that even the most powerful democracy in the world elected a leader such as Trump, who has been seen by many as disregarding international and statutory norms with relative impunity, while the world watches and responds with concern. No individual or party should hold absolute power, something that democracy is meant to prevent. Goa, for its part, has so far been a place where communal harmony has largely endured. However, recent controversies surrounding the remarks made against St Francis Xavier and some Hindu deities are troubling and do not augur well. We, the people of India—that is, Bharat—must not only continue to uphold Goan harmony but also actively protect and respect minorities. Only then can we aspire to remain a nation that lives in peace, balance, and true harmony.
John Eric Gomes, Porvorim
Mandate must prevail
The news report “Defiant Mamata Banerjee refuses to resign as CM” (NT, May 6) describes an unprecedented development in the history of Indian politics and elections, and does not reflect well on a Chief Minister holding a constitutional office. It must be recalled that the people of West Bengal turned out in record numbers during this election, delivering a landslide victory of over 200 seats to the BJP, compared to a paltry 81 seats secured by the Trinamool Congress (TMC). This result clearly indicates a strong wave of anti-incumbency in the state and the electorate’s desire for change after 15 years of TMC rule. Mamata Banerjee should recognise this mandate and humbly accept the verdict of the people, rather than disputing it or alleging a “loot and conspiracy” by the Election Commission of India.
A F Nazareth, Alto Porvorim
Calangute’s lost charm
Once upon a time, Calangute was renowned for its beach shows, football, and other cultural activities (both of which have now ceased). Even the once-famous Calangute Association football ground has been converted into a parking area for domestic tourists. It was regarded as the “Queen of Beaches” across Goa for its natural beauty and peaceful atmosphere. Goans from different parts of the state would flock to Calangute Beach every year during the summer, especially in May, to attend these shows, organise family picnics, and spend time together in a relaxed setting. At that time, the beach was less congested and free from the presence of large numbers of domestic tourists and other disruptive elements. Unfortunately, Goans today have largely stopped visiting Calangute Beach, even for family outings, as it has been overtaken by shack operators, water sports businesses, misbehaving tourists, drug peddlers, call-girl suppliers, touts, and other nuisance elements. In fact, Calangute has lost its old charm and now resembles a concrete jungle, with numerous buildings mushrooming in the surrounding area. It has become heavily overcrowded and congested, leaving little space to relax in the evenings or stroll freely along the beach. Calangute is no longer on the way to decline—it has already been lost, due to the greed of sections of the local population and those responsible in the tourism department.
Jerry Fernandes, Saligao
Unsafe food practices
I am writing to express deep concern regarding the recent tragic incident in Mumbai, where an entire family of four reportedly lost their lives after consuming watermelon. Such reports have understandably caused fear and confusion among the public about the safety of a fruit that is otherwise regarded as refreshing and nutritious. While the incident is deeply alarming, it is important not to draw premature conclusions or stigmatise watermelon as a whole. Experts generally suggest that such cases are more likely linked to contamination—whether due to improper handling, unhygienic storage, or the possible use of harmful chemicals to enhance appearance or shelf life. If true, such practices pose a serious threat to public health and require strict regulatory intervention. Rather than avoiding watermelon altogether, the emphasis should be on awareness and precaution.
Jubel D’Cruz, Mumbai
Consumers should ensure that fruits are purchased from reliable vendors, washed thoroughly before consumption, and that pre-cut fruits sold in open or unhygienic conditions are avoided. At the same time, the authorities must intensify inspections and enforce food safety standards rigorously to prevent such tragedies in the future. When safe and properly handled, watermelon remains a valuable source of hydration and nutrition, particularly during the summer months. Public concern should be guided by scientific understanding rather than panic. I therefore urge the concerned authorities to investigate the matter thoroughly and take all necessary measures to ensure the safety and integrity of food available in our markets.
Jubel D’Cruz, Mumbai
Litigation under scrutiny
The Supreme Court, while hearing a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) relating to its 2006 order on the entry of menstruating women into the Sabarimala Ayyappa Temple, observed that such petitions have increasingly become “paisa interest litigations” and “publicity interest litigations”. It was the former Chief Justice of India, the late P N Bhagwati, who, during his tenure from 1973 onwards, significantly expanded the scope of PILs and set in motion this remarkable judicial innovation. Through several landmark judgments, the Supreme Court sought to correct governmental wrongs and ensure the enforcement of constitutional rights. However, concerns have been raised in certain quarters that, in its zeal to expand access to justice, the judiciary may at times appear to encroach upon the domains of the executive and legislature. It has been argued that social and political engineering should not be the primary function of the courts. Nevertheless, the judiciary’s role remains the protection and enforcement of the rights guaranteed under the Constitution for the common citizen.
Ganapathi Bhat, Akola
