As Goa approaches November 25, 2026, the 516th anniversary of its conquest by Afonso de Albuquerque, history invites moral reflection. Portuguese conquerors arrived professing Christianity, yet their cruelty contradicted Jesus Christ’s teachings. The contrast with contemporary Goa is striking: Christian communities have helped nurture education, healthcare, charity, cultural life, and efforts to safeguard the state’s threatened environment and heritage. Jesus taught, “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you” (Matthew 5:44). He blessed peacemakers and urged mercy. These principles offer a compelling standard for judging imperial conduct without confusing the conquerors’ actions with the faith they professed.
In 1502, Vasco da Gama intercepted the vessel ‘Miri’, carrying Muslim pilgrims and merchants returning from Mecca. Accounts describe hundreds aboard, including women and children. After taking valuables, Portuguese forces burned the vessel despite pleas for mercy. These were helpless travellers, not combatants. Gama could have spared them. Instead, he chose destruction. During that expedition, Portuguese forces bombarded Calicut. Accounts also describe captives being mutilated and their remains sent ashore to intimidate the Zamorin. Such calculated terror transformed human suffering into an instrument of imperial ambition, directly contradicting Christ’s injunctions to compassion.
On 25 November 1510, Albuquerque’s forces captured Goa from the Adilshahi administration. Victory was followed by four days of killing of Muslims. Mosques were burned, fugitives pursued, and property plundered. Civilians and prisoners could have been spared. Instead, religious hostility ac-companied military triumph, turning a change of political control into a catastrophe for families who had little power to resist.
The devastation was not merely a battlefield episode; it continued after the city had fallen. Albuquerque’s own letter to King Manuel I, dated 22 December 1510, reported more than 6,000 Muslim deaths, including women, and described the burning of mosques. This was his reported figure, not an independently verified census. His correspondence presented the destruction as a military achievement rather than an occasion for remorse. That distinction matters: the numbers and descriptions survive in records associated with the conquerors themselves. Their testimony must be read critically but cannot simply be dismissed as a later nationalist invention.
Albuquerque knew how to distinguish groups of civilians. He ordered protection for Brahmins, agricultural workers, and skilled inhabitants whose services were valuable. Such selective protection makes the violence against Muslims disturbing. The massacre was not simply an unavoidable consequence of battle. His correspondence also describes captive Muslim women being married to Portuguese settlers who received incentives. After slaughter, captivity, and dispossession, the circumstances raise profound questions about freedom of consent. Accounts of captives dying inside a burning mosque further expose the terror experienced by the defeated.
The Goa Inquisition, established in 1560, belonged to a later period and must be distinguished from Albuquerque’s conquest. It investigated suspected religious offences, imposed imprisonment and confiscation, and used coercive interrogation. Some condemned prisoners were transferred to secular authorities for execution, including burning. Religious coercion again contradicted the mercy and freedom of conscience that ought to govern human relationships.
Old Goa’s celebrated architecture can obscure this darker history. Visitors readily encounter monumental buildings, but far fewer learn about the people killed during the conquest or those imprisoned and punished under colonial institutions. Remembering these victims need not diminish the city’s spiritual or cultural inheritance. It makes historical understanding more complete. A mature society can cherish architectural beauty while acknowledging the suffering associated with the political order that produced it.
Honest remembrance is neither hostility towards religion nor rejection of cultural heritage. Indeed, the Christianity rooted in Goa today offers a different legacy. Generations of Christian educators, medical professionals, charitable institutions, artists and ordinary citizens have enriched public life. Their service spans religious boundaries and is part of Goa’s shared social inheritance.
Equally significant is the participation of Goan Christians, alongside fellow citizens of other faiths, in efforts to defend forests, rivers, fields, villages, livelihoods and cultural landscapes. Clergy, com-munity organisations and concerned citizens have contributed to public discussion and environ-mental advocacy. Such work embodies stewardship: responsibility for the vulnerable, for neighbours and for generations yet unborn. These efforts deserve recognition without romanticising any community or claiming unanimity. Goa’s environmental struggles involve diverse citizens with different views, united by concern for their homeland. In that shared civic commitment, the teachings of compassion and human dignity acquire practical meaning.
The moral contrast is unmistakable. In 1510, conquest brought killing and dispossession. In modern Goa, many Christians join others in protecting the land and its people through education, service and democratic action. The same faith invoked by imperial commanders has inspired generations to pursue humane purposes wholly unlike those commanders’ deeds.
As Goa marks 516 years since Albuquerque’s conquest, remembrance should neither glorify imperial violence nor burden living communities with inherited guilt. Historical responsibility rests with those who ordered and carried out the atrocities. The documented cruelty of Gama, Albuquerque, and later inquisitorial authorities deserves condemnation. The conquerors carried the Cross to India while betraying Christ’s teachings. The greater glory lies in the compassion that outlived their empire—and in Goans of every faith who work together to preserve what remains of their be-loved homeland.
(Dr Nandkumar M Kamat, who has a doctorate in microbiology, is a scientist and science writer.)